# MATHEMATICS RESEARCH

Engaging with the research presented here will deepen your understanding of the difference and benefits of teaching and learning mathematics instrumentally and relationally, and what the evidence says actually works in mathematics teaching using research-informed strategies.

COUNTING AND GROUPING

Adults assume that learning to count is easy, because we cannot remember the time before we could count. This research explains the principles, the sequence, and the challenges.

Mathematics in the Early Grades: Counting & Cardinality
Victorian State Government’s Education Development Centre explains that even if young children can recite the number sequence (i.e. say one, two, three, etc) we cannot assume that they can count small sets of objects. The important principles and challenges involved in learning to count are identified.

One-to-One Correspondence: Foundation Level
Victorian State Government’s Education Development Centre summarises research on early counting concepts, describing how they develop over time and with experience.

Difficulties Children Face When Learning to Count
Ann Gervasoni from Australian Catholic University’s research finding several common difficulties and issues related to learning to count.

Advances in technology means algorithms and procedures for addition and subtraction are no longer necessary. This research explains that mental strategies to develop reasoning are our focus.

The Empty Number Line and
Janette Bobis’ research on mental computation is now receiving greater emphasis in the curriculum and in classrooms across the world than ever before. Her research demonstrates the importance of the empty number line.

Issues in Place-Value and Multi-digit Addition and Subtraction Learning and Teaching
Karen Fuson’s research suggests that when teaching focuses on algorithms, children do not learn place value concepts or multi-digit addition and subtraction adequately, and that even children who calculate correctly show little understanding of the procedures they are using. (Free login to jstor.org)

The Link Between Place Value and Operations
This book emphasises the vital link between place value and operations, finding that a good understanding of addition, subtraction, and place value is crucial for strategies in multiplication, division, fractions, algebra, and statistics. It explains that students initially use counting to solve addition and subtraction problems, then start to think strategically, first with smaller whole numbers, then with larger ones, and later with fractions, decimals, and integers.

Teachers’ Understanding of Addition and Subtraction with Whole Numbers
George J. Roy’s study examined teachers’ understanding of number concepts and operations, adding and subtracting in base 8 (rather than base 10) to allow prospective teachers to reason about addition and subtraction with whole numbers in similar ways that students’ reason in base 10.

PLACE VALUE

Place value is so much more than naming the column a digit is in. This research explains the deeper understandings about place value, their complexity and importance.

The Development of Structure in the Number System
Noel Thomas from Charles Sturt University, Bathurst NSW’s cross-sectional study assessing children’s understanding of the number system.

Number Sense Series: A Sense of ‘ten’ and Place Value
Jenni Way’s article on the importance of a strong ‘sense of ten’ as a foundation for both place value and mental calculations.

What is a Ten Frame and why is it a useful tool?
South African Numeracy Chair Project at Rhodes University’s article with research and activities using 10 frames for developing early number relationships.

Standard and non-standard place value partitioning
Hilder Road State School’s examples of partitioning numbers using standard and non-standard place value.

Children’s Understanding of Two-Digit Place Value
University of Virginia’s research finding that the development of young children’s number sense and understanding of the base 10 system is essential for the acquisition of more complex number skills in later years

Place Value (page 7)
University of Notre Dame Australia’s research on page 7 explores the complexity of standard place value.

Rethinking Concrete Manipulatives
Clements and McMillen’s NCTM-published research finding the effect of using materials in understanding mathematical concepts depends on the teaching.

Multiplicative Patterns on a Place Value Chart
New York State Common Core Mathematics Curriculum conceptual exploration of the multiplicative patterns of the base ten system, including the relationship to metric measurement.

MULTIPLICATION AND DIVISION

Multiplication and division goes much further than ‘groups’ and ‘tables’. This research explains the importance of multiplicative thinking, and of understanding, intentionally using, generalising, and explaining the distributive property.

The Key Role of Multiplicative Thinking
Di Siemon’s research finds that access to multiplicative thinking has been identified as the single, most important reason for the eight-year range in mathematics achievement in Years 5 to 9, and explains that while elements of multiplicative thinking are represented in the Australian Curriculum, the connections between these and how they contribute to the development of multiplicative thinking over time is not entirely clear. (3rd lecture from top of page)

Di Siemon’s research explains the characteristics of multiplicative thinking as a capacity to work flexibly and efficiently with an extended range of numbers, and an ability to recognise and solve a range of problems involving multiplication or division including direct and indirect proportion, and – the means to communicate this effectively in a variety of ways. The research demonstrates the difference between multiplicative and additive thinking, identifies lack of multiplicative thinking as the major barrier to learning mathematics in the middle years. (Select the blue download button at the top right of the page.)

The Distributive Property
Nelis Vermeulen’s research explains that children have a intuitive grasp of the distributive property, and the importance of developing their capacity to intentionally use it, to generalise it, and to explain it.

FRACTIONS

Fractions are so much more than ‘equal parts’. This research explains the 5 ways to understand fractions, and how to teach fractions multiplicatively.

The Inter-relatedness of the 5 Sub-constructs of Fractions
Charalambous’ research explains that fractions comprise a multifaceted notion encompassing five interrelated subconstructs (part-whole, ratio, operator, quotient and measure), and that when teaching fractions, teachers need to scaffold students to develop a profound understanding of the different interpretations of fractions.

3 Concepts Underpinning the 5 Sub-constructs
Annie Mitchell’s paper demonstrates how the 5 sub-constructs of Fractions are underpinned by three concepts: partitioning, equivalence, and unit-forming, explaining that these concepts provide better categorisation of the underlying fraction concepts.

Unifying the 5 Sub-constructs into 3 Elements
Doug Clarke’s research has used student interviews to unify the 5 sub-constructs into 3 big ideas – identification of the unit, partitioning and the notion of quantity (how “big” a fraction is).

10 Practical Tips for Making Fractions Make Sense
Doug Clarke, Anne Roche, and Annie Mitchell’s paper provides insights into their research, and identifies 10 research-based recommendations for the focus of fractions teaching.

Partitioning to Create Fractions
Di Siemon’s research explains that focusing fractions understanding on partitioning underpins the fraction sub-construct of fractions as division.

Units in Length Measurement
Yanik, Helding, and Flores’ research into the sub-construct of measure explains how the number line is a practical model as the base unit is identified and reiterated from the zero point.

Foundational Understanding Needed for Operating with Fractions
Bruce, Chang, and Flynn’s review examines how the foundational concepts of fractions is the base for adding and subtracting fractions, and proposes a progression of fraction number sense.

Procedural and Conceptual Knowledge
Forrester and Chinnappan’s research distinguished between the procedural and conceptional knowledge of teachers in operating with fractions, finding that procedural knowledge was dominant, leading to a dominance of procedural teaching.

Teaching Fractions for Conceptual Understanding
Fazio and Siegler’s research identified that, although understanding fractions is essential for learning algebra, geometry and other aspects of higher mathematics, students’ difficulties with fractions stem from a lack of conceptual understanding. They recommends ideas for introducing fraction concepts, ideas to help older students understand fraction magnitudes, ways of helping students use fractions to solve rate, ratio and proportion problems, and methods to increase teacher’s conceptual knowledge of fractions.

DECIMALS

Decimals are so much more than the decimal point. This research explains the reason some common misunderstandings arise about decimals.

Decimal Misconceptions
Steinle’s paper identifies that common misconceptions students have about decimals have been caused by procedural knowledge, and suggests remedies involving developing conceptual understanding including the relationship to the denominator in fractions, the importance of ‘one’, and multiplicative place value.